The case is a bit complicated for the two-time Super Bowl MVP, who has a .500 career record as a starter and was a Pro Bowler in just four of his 16 seasons.

The two-time Super Bowl champion, who defeated Tom Brady’s Patriots twice and was never an All-Pro selection, is at the forefront of Thursday’s debate.

With the Class of 2025 about to be revealed, Craig Ellenport and Doug Farrar debate the candidacy of this year’s most polarizing finalist.

It's highly likely that Eli Manning is going to be selected into the 2025 NFL Hall of Fame class this weekend, but the former New York Giants quarterback has no business earning a place there. Manning is certainly a household name,

One of the most heated debates in the NFL could come to an end next week if former New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning is selected to the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Manning, who retired following the 2019 season, is in his first year of eligibility to make the Hall of Fame, and was one of 15 modern-era finalists for the class of 2025.

The NFL gods have pretty much settled the Tom Brady-vs.-Joe Montana question, and we’re still another couple years from a legitimate Tom Brady-vs.-Patrick Mahomes discussion, so that leaves us with one remaining Burning Football Debate: Is Eli Manning a Hall of Famer?

Evan Roberts believes Tom Coughlin did more for the Giants in their run of success than Eli Manning, and says it feels wrong that the head coach won’t be a Hall of Famer first.

On Thursday, the world will find out who the 2025 Pro Football Hall of Fame members will be. Will Giants quarterback Eli Manning be among them?

Will Eli Manning make the Pro Football Hall of Fame? Here are the pros and cons of the Ole Miss and New York Giants QB's professional career